New York Yankees vs Baltimore Orioles Picks and Predictions for Monday, May 11, 2026

By: Cameron Ross Published 05/11/2026, 12:40 AM ET

Yankees vs Orioles Game Information

The New York Yankees will be on the road Monday night for Game 1 of 3 in Baltimore at 6:35 PM against the Baltimore Orioles. New York has 26 wins and 15 losses this season, coming into Monday having lost 4 of the last 5, including 3 in a row to the Milwaukee Brewers. The Baltimore Orioles stay home Monday night with 18 wins and 23 losses, having won 2 of the last 5 following a 1-run victory against the Athletics in their last game to end the 3-game skid. Stay up to date with our MLB Picks.

Yankees Preview

Offensively, New York has been mediocre this season, with a .240 batting average. The Yankees have scored 212 runs on 315 hits. The New York power has been resounding with a .444 team slugging percentage as the Yankees have hit 62 home runs this year. The New York pitching has carried the load with a 3.12 team ERA, but the Yankees have allowed 20 total runs across their last 4 losses. Ben Rice leads the New York offense this season with a .306 batting average. Aaron Judge has a .267 batting average and leads the Yankees with 16 home runs and 30 RBI's this season.

Orioles Preview

Offensively, but Baltimore has been below average this season, with a .233 batting average. The Orioles have scored 179 runs on 309 hits. Baltimore has a .319 OBP and a .385 team slugging percentage. The Baltimore pitching has been horrendous this season, with a 4.84 team ERA, as the Orioles have allowed 14 total runs across their last 3 losses. Taylor Ward leads the Baltimore offense this season with a .262 batting average. Jeremiah Jackson has a .246 batting average and leads the team with 24 RBI's. Gunnar Henderson has a .211 batting average and leads the way for Baltimore with 9 home runs this season.

Yankees vs Orioles Pitching Matchup

Ryan Weathers will be on the bump Monday night for New York and Game 1 of this set. Weathers is 2-2 on the year with a 3.03 ERA across 38.2 innings of work. Baltimore will counter with Brandon Young. Young is 3-1 this season despite a 4.35 ERA across 20.2 innings of action.

Subscribe Now

I authorize Picks And Parlays to send me promotional emails

I understand that I can unsubscribe at any time. I have read and accepted the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy. I consent that Picks And Parlays may use third-party services to process my data.

Terms & Conditions

Yankees vs Orioles Pick

New York is a much better team in this matchup despite their recent skid. Look for the Yankees to jump on Baltimore early Monday night, leading to the easy victory. Take the Yankees to do the work on both sides of the dish as they roll to an easy victory to end their recent skid with a division win in Baltimore.

Pick: New York Yankees -181
Secondary: Under 9
Lean: Ben Rice Over 1.5 Bases

Final Score Prediction: New York Yankees win 5-1.