Same Game Parlay for Yankees vs Red Sox on Friday, September 12 2025

By: Devin Erickson-Sheehy Updated 09/12/2025, 12:07 PM ET

Both teams are both firmly in the AL playoff picture at the moment but the race is tightening. We are honed in on Friday's high stakes tilt at Fenway Park with a same game parlay for Yankees vs Red Sox that pays out at a massive +666 at FanDuel Sportsbook.

Our Same Game Parlay Picks for NYY/BOS:

Yankees Moneyline (-124)
Trevor Story to Record 2+ Total Bases (+115)
Aaron Judge to Record an RBI (+120)

Sign Up Get $30 Premium Picks Credit + Exclusive Offers

Subscribe Now

I authorize Picks And Parlays to send me promotional emails

I understand that I can unsubscribe at any time. I have read and accepted the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy. I consent that Picks And Parlays may use third-party services to process my data.
Terms & Conditions

We have MLB picks for every single game on the Friday night slate, including other key matchups with playoff implications.

Why we Like Yankees Moneyline

The Yankees enter this matchup with a narrow 0.5 lead over Boston in the AL East. Luis Gil takes the mound for New York, and his numbers inspire confidence, posting a 3.31 ERA overall and a dominant 1.27 ERA specifically against Boston. The absence of Roman Anthony could loom large in this series, and we see that playing out in the opener.

Offensively, the Yankees remain MLB’s most dangerous slugging team, already piling up 249 home runs this season. With Aaron Judge and Cody Bellinger anchoring the lineup, New York consistently produces in high-leverage situations. Look for them to tag Lucas Gilito who's underlying metrics are less impressive than the 3.38 ERA he is sporting for the year.

Back the Yanks to take the opener at -124.

Why we Like Trevor Story to Record 2+ Total Bases

On the Red Sox side, Trevor Story has been the engine of their offense, racking up 24 home runs, 91 RBIs, and a .443 slugging percentage this season. Story’s bat plays perfectly at Fenway Park, where the short gaps and inviting wall boost his doubles power, an area where Boston leads all of MLB.

Gil can be dominant, but when he falls behind in the count, he will give up hard contact. Story’s aggressive approach and recent form suggest a strong chance to reach two or more total bases, whether with a few singles , a double, or even finding the seats.

Why we Like Aaron Judge to Record an RBI

Aaron Judge continues to be the heartbeat of the Yankees’ offense, driving in 100 runs already this season while batting .322 with 46 homers. After going deep twice last night, we see a carryover effect in the friendly hitting confines of Fenway Park. We expect plenty of base traffic tonight, positioning Judge to come through with a ribby, keeping in mind he is perfectly capable of driving himself in on one mistake pitch.

Against Boston’s pitching, Judge has historically thrived, and with the stakes high, expect him to rise to the moment. Adding Judge to record an RBI ties this parlay together with a power bat that has delivered time and time again.