Seton Hall Pirates vs Butler Bulldogs Picks and Predictions for Sunday February 15 2026

By: Kim Smith Published 02/15/2026, 12:50 AM ET

The Seton Hall Pirates travel to Hinkle Fieldhouse to take on the Butler Bulldogs on Sunday, February 15, 2026. Tip-off is set for 6:00 PM ET with the game airing on FS1. Seton Hall enters this Big East matchup as a 1.5-point favorite, and the total is listed at 142. At the time of this writing, the moneyline odds were not released. Be sure to check out our free college basketball picks for more daily betting insight and expert analysis.

Pirates Leaning on Defense and Discipline

Seton Hall comes into this contest at 17-8 overall and 7-7 in Big East play, including a 7-7 conference road record. The Pirates have won three of their last five games, recently defeating Providence 87-80, Marquette 69-64, and Xavier 86-68 while falling narrowly to Creighton 69-68 and losing to Villanova 72-60. They’ve been competitive in nearly every conference matchup.

The Pirates average 72.0 points per game while allowing just 65.2, one of the stronger defensive marks in the conference. They shoot 44% from the field and grab 36.0 rebounds per contest. Seton Hall also averages 13.2 assists per game, showing solid offensive balance.

Defense is clearly the identity of this team. Seton Hall averages 5.4 blocks and 9.6 steals per game, consistently disrupting opposing offenses. Their ability to generate turnovers and protect the rim gives them a significant edge, particularly in slower-paced Big East matchups.

Subscribe Now

I authorize Picks And Parlays to send me promotional emails

I understand that I can unsubscribe at any time. I have read and accepted the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy. I consent that Picks And Parlays may use third-party services to process my data.

Terms & Conditions

Bulldogs Trying to Stop the Slide at Home

Butler enters this matchup at 13-12 overall and 4-10 in conference play, including a 4-10 Big East home record. The Bulldogs have dropped five straight games, recently losing to UConn 80-70, Marquette 70-55, Providence 97-87 in double overtime, Georgetown 77-64, and St. John’s 92-70. Defensive breakdowns have played a major role during this skid.

Butler averages 80.7 points per game but allows 77.4, reflecting a team that can score but struggles to consistently get stops. They shoot 46% from the field and pull down 38.2 rebounds per contest. The Bulldogs also average 15.7 assists per game, showing they move the ball well offensively.

While Butler’s offense can be explosive, their defensive inconsistency is concerning. Allowing over 77 points per game against a disciplined Seton Hall team could make it difficult to control tempo in this matchup.

Seton Hall Pirates vs Butler Bulldogs Pick

Seton Hall Pirates vs Butler Bulldogs Spread Pick

Pick: Seton Hall -1.5

Seton Hall’s defensive consistency gives them the edge here. Butler has struggled defensively during its five-game losing streak, and the Pirates’ ability to generate steals and protect the rim should translate into key stops. In what projects to be a competitive game, laying the small number with the more consistent team is the play.

Seton Hall Pirates vs Butler Bulldogs Total Pick

Pick: Under 142

I’m leaning toward the under in this matchup. Seton Hall allows just 65.2 points per game and prefers a controlled tempo. While Butler can score, the Pirates’ defensive pressure should limit easy looks. This feels like a game that settles in the high 130s.

Final Score Prediction: Seton Hall 72, Butler 68

Betting on College Basketball?

Join Picks and Parlays premium for free and get a free $30 coupon with code FREE30
Get started and wager on college hoops today with our favorite online sportsbooks
Claim a CBB betting bonus offer with the best sportsbook promos