Pittsburgh Penguins vs Toronto Maple Leafs Picks & Predictions Tuesday December 23 2025
The Pittsburgh Penguins vs Toronto Maple Leafs showdown arrives at a critical point in the 2025-26 NHL season. Both clubs are hovering around .500, with the Penguins bringing road momentum and the Maple Leafs looking to snap inconsistencies at home. Bettors can find deeper insights and game-day breakdowns through our Free NHL picks before placing their wagers.
Pittsburgh Penguins: Road Offense Carrying Momentum
The Pittsburgh Penguins head into this road matchup with a 15-11-9 record overall and 8-5-4 away. Their last five games show high-event play: a 4-3 shootout win versus Montreal on December 21, a 4-0 loss at Montreal on December 20, a 4-0 loss at Ottawa on December 18, a 6-4 loss versus Edmonton on December 16, and a 5-4 overtime loss versus Utah on December 14. They're averaging 3.03 goals for per game while allowing 3.09, with 28.5 shots for and 28.3 against.
Sidney Crosby leads with 37 points (20 goals, 17 assists), including 8 power-play goals on 84 shots. Erik Karlsson adds 23 assists (8 on power play). The power play is at 29.6% (29 goals), and the penalty kill at 80.8%. Goaltending includes Stuart Skinner (11-10-4, 2.94 GAA, .886 SV%) and Arturs Silovs (5-5-6, 3.22 GAA, .889 SV%). Injuries: Brunicke out (January 8), Lizotte IR (December 30), Malkin IR (December 30), Kettles out (September 15), Jones IR (January 17).
Road play (8-5-4) with high scoring and PP strength. Recent shootout win shows clutch, but losses highlight defensive gaps without Malkin.
Sign Up Get $30 Premium Picks Credit + Exclusive Offers
Subscribe Now
Toronto Maple Leafs: Home Inconsistencies with Injuries
The Toronto Maple Leafs sit at 15-15-5 overall and 10-5-5 at home. Their last five: a 5-1 loss at Dallas on December 21, a 5-3 loss at Nashville on December 20, a 4-0 loss at Washington on December 18, a 3-2 win versus Chicago on December 16, and a 6-3 loss versus Edmonton on December 13. They're averaging 3.11 goals for per game while allowing 3.34, with 26.9 shots for and 31.1 against.
William Nylander leads with 36 points (11 goals, 25 assists), including 5 power-play assists. John Tavares has 14 goals (2 on power play) on 96 shots. The power play is at 13.3% (12 goals), and the penalty kill at 83.2%. Goaltending includes Dennis Hildeby (2-5-3, 2.96 GAA, .911 SV%), Anthony Stolarz (6-5-1, 3.51 GAA, .884 SV%, IR January 3), and Joseph Woll (5-4-1, 2.46 GAA, .925 SV%). Injuries: Rifai IR-LT (December 23), Stolarz IR (January 3), Tanev IR (December 30), Carlo IR (January 3), Mermis IR (January 10).
Home average (10-5-5) but recent losses show struggles. Defensive injuries expose shots against (31.1 SA/G).
Pittsburgh Penguins vs Toronto Maple Leafs: High-Event Atlantic Clash
This game features high-scoring potential with Penguins' PP (29.6%) and Crosby against Toronto's leaky D (3.34 GA/G, injuries). Toronto's home offense meets Penguins' road volume.
Goaltending close, both tandems inconsistent. Special teams favor Penguins PP.
Betting Trends and Over/Under Outlook
Stats lean Over with combined 6.45 total goals average and recent high-scoring games. Both allowing 3+ GA/G. Lines imply Maple Leafs favorites (+2 on Penguins? wait +1), total likely 6.5 +105.
Trends: Penguins games high-event, Toronto home variable but leaky.
Game-Changing Factors
Penguins Malkin/Lizotte out hurts depth. Toronto defensive injuries heavy. Road Penguins (8-5-4) vs. home Leafs (10-5-5). Special teams and Crosby key.
Key Players to Watch
Crosby (37P, 20G) and Karlsson (23A) lead Penguins. Nylander (36P) and Tavares (14G) pace Leafs. Skinner/Silovs vs. Hildeby/Woll.
Pittsburgh Penguins vs Toronto Maple Leafs Pick and Prediction
I'm taking the Pittsburgh Penguins as road underdogs. Toronto's defensive injuries and high shots against (31.1 SA/G) play into Penguins' volume and elite PP (29.6%) led by Crosby (37P). Leafs home average but recent losses show cracks, Penguins road solid (8-5-4). Betting on sports and on the Penguins is easy, but even easier if you use the best sportsbooks. Make sure you know about how the fans are looking on prediction markets for the Maple Leafs with the Novig promo code. Make sure when you place your bet on Penguins vs Maple Leafs you are using the BetMGM bonus code.
My top play is Penguins moneyline + whatever—I'd take up to +140. Prop lean: Sidney Crosby anytime goal; hot.
Pick: Pittsburgh Penguins Moneyline
Lean: Sidney Crosby Anytime Goalscorer
Never Tried Picks and Parlays? Now Is Your Chance
- Get your first daily picks package for ONLY $1 using coupon code BUCK
- If the pick loses, we credit your account with 3 Flex Picks
- If the pick wins, we still give you 1 Flex Pick on the house
- Win or lose, you walk away ahead. One dollar. No catch.
Spend $10 Get 200 in Bonus Picks
$200 in No Sweat Entries + A Free Pick
Get 100% on any coins purchase up to $100
